Surveillance Technology has become increasingly prevalent in Nigeria, particularly with the rise of remote work arrangements. While these tools aim to measure Productivity and ensure quality assurance, they also raise concerns about privacy, trust, and ethics. As Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella notes, this “Productivity Paranoia” can breed distrust between workers and managers, especially when they are not explicitly informed about the monitoring practices. Measuring employee productivity is crucial for ensuring proper compensation and appraisal.
However, with the shift to remote work, employers have had to rely on surveillance technologies to monitor productivity virtually. These technologies range from simple time trackers to screen capture software, and even extreme measures like always-on webcams during work hours. Some employers believe that supervision is essential for quality output, while others argue that productivity is a better metric to measure than activity. The types of surveillance technologies used in Nigeria include keylogging, screen capturing, activity monitoring software, and webcam surveillance.
Labour laws don’t explicitly address surveillance in Nigeria.
Keylogging involves tracking every keystroke made on a computer, which can raise privacy concerns if not properly secured. Screen-capturing technology takes periodic screenshots of an employee’s computer screen, providing a visual record of their activities. Activity monitoring software tracks active and idle times on an employee’s computer, Logging when the computer is being used and when it is idle. Webcam surveillance uses webcams or PC cameras to monitor employees during work hours, which can be considered highly invasive.
The legal implications of using surveillance technologies in Nigeria are not explicitly addressed in labour laws. However, legal practitioners emphasize the importance of obtaining informed consent from employees before monitoring them, especially when using their personal devices. Companies must communicate clearly about monitoring practices, use surveillance minimally, and ensure Data Security and privacy. Nigerian HR tech startups like SeamlessHR and Cadana incorporate monitoring features into their platforms, mainly activity monitoring through time and attendance tracking.
Specific regulations needed to ensure accountability.
Yet, the use of surveillance technologies can have downsides. Employees may feel stressed and anxious about being constantly monitored, leading to decreased morale and trust issues. Some employees have devised systems to simulate activity on their devices, which can be considered unacceptable by employers. Additionally, the use of unauthorized applications on company devices can pose significant risks. Instead of relying on intrusive surveillance, employers can explore alternative methods to maintain productivity. Setting clear goals and expectations, regular check-ins and feedback sessions, encouraging self-reporting and accountability, and using project management tools to track progress can be more effective and ethical ways to manage remote teams. By finding a balance between productivity and privacy, employers can create a trusting and thriving work environment.
In Nigeria, the National Labor Act and the Education/what-is-data-protection/" target="_blank">Data Protection Regulation 2019 provide some guidance on employee privacy and data protection. However, more specific regulations on Employee Surveillance are needed to ensure that employers are held accountable for their monitoring practices. Employers must prioritize transparency, consent, and data security to avoid legal and reputational consequences. Also, employers must consider the potential impact of surveillance on employee well-being and Mental Health. Constant monitoring can lead to feelings of micromanaging, which can negatively affect employee motivation and job satisfaction. Employers must prioritize creating a positive work Culture that values trust, respect, and open communication.
Related Article: Gov’t dedicated to boost worker-employer comm
To sum up, employee surveillance in Nigeria requires careful consideration of legal and ethical implications. Employers must navigate the fine line between measuring productivity and respecting employee privacy, ensuring that any monitoring practices are transparent, secure, and minimal. By exploring alternative methods and prioritizing trust and communication, employers can create a positive and productive work environment for their remote teams. As the remote work landscape continues to evolve, it is essential that employers prioritize employee privacy and well-being, ensuring that surveillance technologies are used responsibly and ethically.
